You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Context: I am writing tooling that handles the auth-build-push of container images for other teams to use. Users are allowed to use any of the supported config files.
Use case: The tooling needs to override some attributes like tags, outputs and annotations. To do this I would prefer writing a JSON file on disk with the overrides, and then provide it to bake:
Problem: As I tried to express in the line above, the usage of --file to override implies that the user's --file is specified. There is therefore no way to use the automatic config file detection and specify an additional file to consider at the end.
Another subtle problem is that the .json files typically take precedence over the .hcl files:
(...)
docker-bake.json
docker-bake.override.json
docker-bake.hcl
docker-bake.override.hcl
Most people here use docker-bake.hcl, leaving only docker-bake.override.hcl as the file I could use for this purpose. Unfortunately, I don't have an HCL parser in my context (it's a small actions/github-script javascript snippet that uses the builtin libraries), so I was hoping to output a JSON file instead. Since the "override" json is read before the normal "hcl" bake file, this solution won't work.
If this order was slightly altered, then it would feel natural for tooling to produce an "override" file:
(...)
docker-bake.json
docker-bake.hcl
docker-bake.override.json
docker-bake.override.hcl
Even though the order of precedence is very well documented, it does feel odd that some "override" files are then overridden by non-override files (e.g.: docker-bake.override.json is overridden by docker-bake.hcl which isn't what one would expect before reading the docs.)
Current approach: I am using the --set CLI argument instead of a file-based override. However this doesn't feel as clean and I have to be careful about quoting/escaping.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Description
Context: I am writing tooling that handles the auth-build-push of container images for other teams to use. Users are allowed to use any of the supported config files.
Use case: The tooling needs to override some attributes like tags, outputs and annotations. To do this I would prefer writing a JSON file on disk with the overrides, and then provide it to bake:
Problem: As I tried to express in the line above, the usage of
--file
to override implies that the user's--file
is specified. There is therefore no way to use the automatic config file detection and specify an additional file to consider at the end.Something like this would be useful:
Another subtle problem is that the
.json
files typically take precedence over the.hcl
files:Most people here use
docker-bake.hcl
, leaving onlydocker-bake.override.hcl
as the file I could use for this purpose. Unfortunately, I don't have an HCL parser in my context (it's a smallactions/github-script
javascript snippet that uses the builtin libraries), so I was hoping to output a JSON file instead. Since the "override" json is read before the normal "hcl" bake file, this solution won't work.If this order was slightly altered, then it would feel natural for tooling to produce an "override" file:
Even though the order of precedence is very well documented, it does feel odd that some "override" files are then overridden by non-override files (e.g.:
docker-bake.override.json
is overridden bydocker-bake.hcl
which isn't what one would expect before reading the docs.)Current approach: I am using the
--set
CLI argument instead of a file-based override. However this doesn't feel as clean and I have to be careful about quoting/escaping.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: