Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
282 lines (211 loc) · 12.9 KB

README.md

File metadata and controls

282 lines (211 loc) · 12.9 KB

SuperIntervals

A fast, memory-efficient data structure for interval intersection queries. SuperIntervals uses a novel superset-index approach that maintains intervals in position-sorted order, enabling cache-friendly searches and SIMD-optimized counting.

Features:

  • Linear-time index construction from sorted intervals
  • Cache-friendly querying
  • SIMD acceleration (AVX2/Neon) for counting operations
  • Minimal memory overhead (one size_t per interval)
  • Available for C++, Rust, Python, and C
  • Optional Eytzinger memory layout for slightly faster queries (C++/Rust only)
  • No dependencies, header only

Quick Start

  • Intervals are considered end-inclusive
  • The index() function must be called before any queries
  • Found intervals are returned in reverse position-sorted order

🐍 Python

from superintervals import IntervalSet

iset = IntervalSet()
iset.add(10, 20, 'A')
iset.index()
overlaps = iset.find_overlaps(8, 20)

⚙️ C++

#include "SuperIntervals.hpp"

SuperIntervals<int, std::string> intervals;
intervals.add(1, 5, "A");
intervals.index();
std::vector<std::string> results;
intervals.findOverlaps(4, 9, results);

🦀 Rust

use super_intervals::SuperIntervals;

let mut intervals = SuperIntervals::new();
intervals.add(1, 5, "A");
intervals.index();
let mut results = Vec::new();
intervals.find_overlaps(4, 11, &mut results);

Test programs

Test programs expect plain text BED files and only assess chr1 records - other chromosomes are ignored.

C++ program compares SuperIntervals, ImplicitIntervalTree, IntervalTree and NCLS:

cd test; make
./run-cpp-libs a.bed b.bed

Rust program:

RUSTFLAGS="-Ctarget-cpu=native" cargo run --release --example bed-intersect-si
cargo run --release --example bed-intersect-si a.bed b.bed

Benchmark

Benchmark

SuperIntervals (SI) was compared with:

Coitrees (Rust: https://github.com/dcjones/coitrees)
Implicit Interval Tree (C++: https://github.com/lh3/cgranges)
Interval Tree (C++: https://github.com/ekg/intervaltree)
Nested Containment List (C: https://github.com/pyranges/ncls/tree/master/ncls/src)

Main results:

  • Finding interval intersections is roughly ~1.5-3x faster than the next best library (Coitrees for Rust, Implicit Interval Tree for C++), with some exceptions. Coitrees-s was faster for one test (ONT reads, sorted DB53 reads).
  • The SIMD counting performance of coitrees and superintervals is similar.

Datasets:

  • rna / anno RNA-seq reads and annotations from cgranges repository
  • ONT reads nanopore alignments from sample PAO33946 chr1, converted to bed format
  • DB53 reads paired-end reads from sample DB53, NCBI BioProject PRJNA417592, chr1, converted to bed format
  • mito-b, mito-a paired-end reads from sample DB53 chrM, converted to bed format (mito-b and mito-a are the same)
  • genes UCSC genes from hg19

Test programs use internal timers and print data to stdout, measuring the index time, and time to find all intersections. Other steps such as file IO are ignored. Test programs also only assess chr1 bed records - other chromosomes are ignored. For 'chrM' records, the M was replaced with 1 using sed. Data were assessed in position sorted and random order. Datasets can be found on the Releases page, and the test/run_tools.sh script has instructions for how to repeat the benchmark.

Timings were in microseconds using an i9-11900K, 64 GB, 2TB NVMe machine.

Finding interval intersections

Coitrees-s uses the SortedQuerent version of coitrees
SI = superintervals. Eytz refers to the eytzinger layout. -rs is the Rust implementation.

Intervals in sorted order

Coitrees Coitrees-s SuperIntervals-rs SuperIntervalsEytz-rs ImplicitITree-C++ IntervalTree-C++ NCLS-C SuperIntervals-C++ SuperIntervalsEytz-C++
DB53 reads, ONT reads 1668 3179 757 757 3831 44404 10642 1315 1358
DB53 reads, genes 55 84 21 21 122 109 291 42 40
ONT reads, DB53 reads 6504 3354 3859 3854 17949 12280 30772 5290 4462
anno, rna 50 35 18 18 127 90 208 29 22
genes, DB53 reads 1171 1018 301 296 3129 1315 1780 442 323
mito-b, mito-a 34769 34594 16971 16952 93900 107660 251707 33177 32985
rna, anno 31 23 21 20 70 55 233 28 27

Intervals in random order

Coitrees Coitrees-s SuperIntervals-rs SuperIntervalsEytz-rs ImplicitITree-C++ IntervalTree-C++ NCLS-C SuperIntervals-C++ SuperIntervalsEytz-C++
DB53 reads, ONT reads 2943 4663 1356 1355 6505 46743 11947 2491 2169
DB53 reads, genes 78 130 27 26 170 125 305 58 51
ONT reads, DB53 reads 16650 18931 16116 16037 38677 27832 53452 23003 23232
anno, rna 89 105 54 54 188 143 294 58 60
genes, DB53 reads 2222 2424 1693 1684 4490 2701 3605 1251 1749
mito-b, mito-a 38030 86309 18326 18368 125336 118321 256293 42195 41695
rna, anno 53 73 45 45 137 83 311 52 52

Counting interval intersections

Intervals in sorted order

Coitrees SuperIntervals-rs SuperIntervalsEytz-rs SuperIntervals-C++ SuperIntervalsEytz-C++
DB53 reads, ONT reads 551 370 371 241 263
DB53 reads, genes 28 12 12 8 7
ONT reads, DB53 reads 2478 1909 1890 2209 1312
anno, rna 26 14 14 22 11
genes, DB53 reads 747 321 336 446 290
mito-b, mito-a 6894 6727 6746 3088 2966
rna, anno 9 13 13 12 10

Intervals in random order

Coitrees SuperIntervals-rs SuperIntervalsEytz-rs SuperIntervals-C++ SuperIntervalsEytz-C++
DB53 reads, ONT reads 1988 972 969 1016 778
DB53 reads, genes 53 20 20 16 13
ONT reads, DB53 reads 6692 8864 8733 8182 9523
anno, rna 52 49 48 47 50
genes, DB53 reads 1503 1628 1592 1120 1623
mito-b, mito-a 14354 7579 7600 4442 4383
rna, anno 22 30 29 25 25

Python

Install using pip install superintervals

from superintervals import IntervalSet

iset = IntervalSet(with_data=True)

# Add interval start, end, identifier. Integer values are supported
iset.add(10, 20, 0)
iset.add(19, 18, 1)
iset.add(8, 11, 2)

# Index method must be called before queries
iset.index()

iset.any_overlaps(8, 20)
# >>> True

iset.count_overlaps(8, 20)
# >>> 3

iset.find_overlaps(8, 20)
# >>> [1, 0, 2]

iset.set_search_interval(8, 20)
for itv in iset:
    print(itv)

# >>> (19, 18, 1) 
# >>> (10, 20, 0) 
# >>> (8, 11, 2)

Cpp

#include <iostream>
#include <vector>
#include "SuperIntervals.hpp"

int main() {
    // Create a SuperIntervals instance for integer intervals with string data
    // Specify with S, T template types
    SuperIntervals<int, std::string> intervals;

    // Add some intervals
    intervals.add(1, 5, "Interval A");
    intervals.add(3, 7, "Interval B");
    intervals.add(6, 10, "Interval C");
    intervals.add(8, 12, "Interval D");

    // Index the intervals (must be called before querying)
    intervals.index();

    // Find overlaps for the range [4, 9]
    std::vector<std::string> overlaps;
    intervals.findOverlaps(4, 9, overlaps);

    // Print the overlapping intervals
    for (const auto& interval : overlaps) {
        std::cout << interval << std::endl;
    }
    
    // Count the intervals instead
    std::cout << "Count: " << intervals.countOverlaps(4, 9) << std::endl;
    
    // Count stabbed intervals at point 7
    std::cout << "Number of intervals containing point 7: " << intervals.countStabbed(7) << std::endl;

    return 0;
}

There is also a SuperIntervalsEytz subclasses that can be used. SuperIntervalsEytz uses an Eytzinger memory layout that can sometimes offer faster query times at the cost of higher memory usage and slower indexing time.

Rust

Fetch using cargo add.

use super_intervals::SuperIntervals;

fn main() {
    // Create a new instance of SuperIntervals
    let mut intervals = SuperIntervals::new();

    // Add some intervals with associated data of type T
    intervals.add(1, 5, "Interval A");
    intervals.add(10, 15, "Interval B");
    intervals.add(7, 12, "Interval C");

    // Call index() to prepare the intervals for queries
    intervals.index();

    // Query for overlapping intervals with a range (4, 11)
    let mut found_intervals = Vec::new();
    intervals.find_overlaps(4, 11, &mut found_intervals);
    
    // Display found intervals
    for interval in found_intervals {
        println!("Found overlapping interval: {}", interval);
    }

    // Count overlaps with a range (4, 11)
    let overlap_count = intervals.count_overlaps(4, 11);
    println!("Number of overlapping intervals: {}", overlap_count);
}

There is also SuperIntervalsEytz implementation. SuperIntervalsEytz uses an Eytzinger memory layout that can sometimes offer faster query times at the cost of higher memory usage and slower indexing time.

Acknowledgements

  • The rust test program borrows heavily from the coitrees package
  • The superset-index implemented here exploits a similar interval ordering as described in Schmidt 2009 "Interval Stabbing Problems in Small Integer Ranges". However, the superset-index has several advantages including
    1. An implicit memory layout
    2. General purpose implementation (not just small integer ranges)
    3. SIMD counting algorithm
  • The Eytzinger layout was adapted from Sergey Slotin, Algorithmica