diff --git a/controllers/game.py b/controllers/game.py
index b6900fc..1f64f3d 100644
--- a/controllers/game.py
+++ b/controllers/game.py
@@ -91,7 +91,7 @@ def post(self):
 
         # Incorrect number of players:
         if len(url_keys) != 4:
-            players = Player.query(Player.deleted == False).order(Player.name)
+            players = Player.query(Player.deleted == False).order(-Player.last_played, -Player.total_games)
             model = {
                 'players':players,
                 'error':'Please select exactly 4 players'