Use `--list` for `branch` and `tag` tab expansion #864

AndreasHassing · 2021-07-06T14:09:57Z

To improve performance of those tab expansions, which are currently sub-optimal in git repos with a lot of branches.

for branch, --list has been available since 1.7.8
- https://github.com/git/git/blob/ecbdaf0899161c067986e9d9d564586d4b045d62/Documentation/RelNotes/1.7.8.txt#L25
for tag, --list has been available since 1.7.10
- https://github.com/git/git/blob/142430338477d9d1bb25be66267225fb58498d92/Documentation/RelNotes/1.7.10.txt#L128

This is a major performance improvement I've been using locally. Seeing that posh-git has moved to require git v2 or higher, this feature will be in all git versions using posh-git and I thought to share it.

Often times in monolithic repositories at work I used to wait for multiple seconds for branch and tag name completion to succeed, this offloads most of the work to the git engine.

AndreasHassing · 2021-07-07T07:57:07Z

Test failures with errors like:

    Expected: 'git checkout -b newbranch'
    But was:  'Invoke-GitFunction -b newbranch'

Come from PR #855 and are not related to this change.

Edit: actually, I am not sure. The tests pass in the master build, but in my PR and also #862, the builds fail for the same test failures. Odd.

dahlbyk · 2021-07-07T14:55:39Z

I'll take a look. Thanks for the contribution!

dscho · 2021-12-10T10:01:57Z

Test failures with errors like:

    Expected: 'git checkout -b newbranch'
    But was:  'Invoke-GitFunction -b newbranch'

I saw the same and debugged a little bit. Turns out that if I replace the script scope with global, like so:

diff --git a/test/GitProxyFunctionExpansion.Tests.ps1 b/test/GitProxyFunctionExpansion.Tests.ps1
index 9ef606d..9b253b1 100644
--- a/test/GitProxyFunctionExpansion.Tests.ps1
+++ b/test/GitProxyFunctionExpansion.Tests.ps1
@@ -28,34 +28,34 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             }
         }
         It 'Expands a proxy function with parameters' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
             $result = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction -b newbranch'
             $result | Should -Be 'git checkout -b newbranch'
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf -b newbranch')
         }
         It 'Expands a multiline proxy function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
             $result = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "Invoke-GitFunction ```r`n-b ```r`nnewbranch"
             $result | Should -Be 'git checkout -b newbranch'
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "igf ```r`n-b ```r`nnewbranch")
         }
         It 'Does not expand the proxy function name if there is no preceding whitespace before backtick newlines' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "Invoke-GitFunction```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch" | Should -Be "Invoke-GitFunction```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch"
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "igf```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch" | Should -Be "igf```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch"
         }
         It 'Does not expand the proxy function name if there is no preceding non-newline whitespace before any backtick newlines' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "Invoke-GitFunction ```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch" | Should -Be "Invoke-GitFunction ```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch"
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "igf ```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch" | Should -Be "igf ```r`n-b```r`nnewbranch"
         }
         It 'Does not expand the proxy function name if the preceding whitespace before backtick newlines are newlines' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "Invoke-GitFunction`r`n```r`n-b`r`n```r`nnewbranch" | Should -Be "Invoke-GitFunction`r`n```r`n-b`r`n```r`nnewbranch"
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction "igf`r`n```r`n-b`r`n```r`nnewbranch" | Should -Be "igf`r`n```r`n-b`r`n```r`nnewbranch"
         }
         It 'Does not expand the proxy function if there is no trailing space' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction' | Should -Be 'Invoke-GitFunction'
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf' | Should -Be 'igf'
         }
@@ -85,7 +85,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             }
         }
         It 'Expands a single line function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git checkout $args
             }
             $result = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
@@ -93,7 +93,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands a single line function with short parameter' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git checkout -b $args
             }
             $result = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
@@ -101,7 +101,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands a single line function with long parameter' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git checkout --detach $args
             }
             $result = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
@@ -109,7 +109,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands a single line with piped function suffix' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git checkout --detach $args | Write-Host
             }
             $result = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
@@ -117,7 +117,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands the first line in function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git checkout $args
                 $a = 5
                 Write-Host $null
@@ -127,7 +127,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands the middle line in function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5
                 git checkout $args
                 Write-Host $null
@@ -137,7 +137,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands the last line in function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5
                 Write-Host $null
                 git checkout $args
@@ -147,7 +147,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands semicolon delimited functions' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5; git checkout $args; Write-Host $null;
             }
             $result = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
@@ -155,7 +155,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands mixed semicolon delimited and newline functions' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5; Write-Host $null
                 git checkout $args; Write-Host $null;
             }
@@ -164,7 +164,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands mixed semicolon delimited and newline multiline functions' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5; Write-Host $null
                 git `
                 checkout `
@@ -175,7 +175,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands simultaneously semicolon delimited and newline functions' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5;
                 Write-Host $null;
                 git checkout $args;
@@ -186,7 +186,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands multiline function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git `
                 checkout `
                 $args
@@ -196,7 +196,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands multiline function that terminates with semicolon on new line' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git `
                 checkout `
                 $args `
@@ -207,7 +207,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands multiline function with short parameter' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git `
                 checkout `
                 -b `
@@ -218,7 +218,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Expands multiline function with long parameter' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git `
                 checkout `
                 --detach `
@@ -229,21 +229,21 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' )
         }
         It 'Does not expand a single line with piped function prefix' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 "master" | git checkout --detach $args
             }
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction ' | Should -Be 'Invoke-GitFunction '
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' | Should -Be 'igf '
         }
         It 'Does not expand function if $args is not present' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 git checkout
             }
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction ' | Should -Be 'Invoke-GitFunction '
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' | Should -Be 'igf '
         }
         It 'Does not expand function if $args is not attached to the git function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5
                 git checkout
                 Write-Host $args
@@ -252,7 +252,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' | Should -Be 'igf '
         }
         It 'Does not expand multiline function if $args is not attached to the git function' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5
                 git `
                 checkout
@@ -262,7 +262,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf ' | Should -Be 'igf '
         }
         It 'Does not expand multiline function backtick newlines are not preceded with whitespace' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction {
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction {
                 $a = 5
                 git`
                 checkout`
@@ -278,7 +278,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             if(Test-Path -Path Function:\Invoke-GitFunction) {
                 Rename-Item -Path Function:\Invoke-GitFunction -NewName Invoke-GitFunctionBackup
             }
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git checkout $args }
         }
         AfterEach {
             if(Test-Path -Path Function:\Invoke-GitFunction) {
@@ -320,14 +320,14 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             }
         }
         It 'Tab completes without subcommands' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git whatever $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git whatever $args }
             $functionText = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
             $result = & $module GitTabExpansionInternal $functionText
 
             $result | Should -Be @()
         }
         It 'Tab completes bisect subcommands' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git bisect $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git bisect $args }
             $functionText = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
             $result = & $module GitTabExpansionInternal $functionText
 
@@ -342,7 +342,7 @@ Describe 'Proxy Function Expansion Tests' {
             $result2 -contains 'skip' | Should -Be $true
         }
         It 'Tab completes remote subcommands' {
-            function script:Invoke-GitFunction { git remote $args }
+            function global:Invoke-GitFunction { git remote $args }
             $functionText = & $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'Invoke-GitFunction '
             $result = & $module GitTabExpansionInternal $functionText

it kind of works, I only get errors regarding igf:

[-] Proxy Function Expansion Tests.Proxy Function Name TabExpansion Tests.Expands a proxy function with parameters 58ms (56ms|2ms)
 at $result | Should -Be (& $module Expand-GitProxyFunction 'igf -b newbranch'), C:\git-sdk-64\usr\src\posh-git\test\GitProxyFunctionExpansion.Tests.ps1:34
 at <ScriptBlock>, C:\git-sdk-64\usr\src\posh-git\test\GitProxyFunctionExpansion.Tests.ps1:34
 Expected strings to be the same, but they were different.
 Expected length: 16
 Actual length:   25
 Strings differ at index 0.
 Expected: 'igf -b newbranch'
 But was:  'git checkout -b newbranch'

[...]

AndreasHassing · 2022-03-17T16:12:24Z

Hi @dahlbyk, any chance to get this in? Is there something I need to do to prepare it better for merge? 😊

Thank you in advance.

dahlbyk · 2022-03-27T09:28:41Z

Hi @dahlbyk, any chance to get this in? Is there something I need to do to prepare it better for merge? 😊

I've finally managed to come out of my virtual coma. You should find all tests passing if you rebase onto master.

I did just merge #868, which seems to conflict with your change.

AndreasHassing · 2022-03-27T18:03:29Z

Hi @dahlbyk, any chance to get this in? Is there something I need to do to prepare it better for merge? 😊

I've finally managed to come out of my virtual coma. You should find all tests passing if you rebase onto master.

I did just merge #868, which seems to conflict with your change.

Fixed the merge conflict, thanks :).

dahlbyk · 2022-03-27T18:42:02Z

Fixed the merge conflict

Great! Anything immediately obvious to you about the linux/macos failures?

AndreasHassing · 2022-03-27T19:15:16Z

Fixed the merge conflict

Great! Anything immediately obvious to you about the linux/macos failures?

No, but I feel like it is caused by what I did since I touch branch filtering in my changes.

I'll take a look tomorrow to try and fix the issues 😊.

dahlbyk

Failures will probably be easier to troubleshoot if you adjust the asserts:

-$result -contains 'master' | Should -Be $true
+$result | Should -Contain 'master'

src/GitTabExpansion.ps1

rkeithhill · 2022-03-27T19:49:49Z

Failures will probably be easier to troubleshoot if you adjust the asserts:
-$result -contains 'master' | Should -Be $true
+$result | Should -Contain 'master'

Yup,

To improve performance of those tab expansions, which are currently sub-optimal in git repos with a lot of branches. * for `branch`, `--list` has been available since 1.7.8 * https://github.com/git/git/blob/ecbdaf0899161c067986e9d9d564586d4b045d62/Documentation/RelNotes/1.7.8.txt#L25 * for `tag`, `--list` has been available since 1.7.10 * https://github.com/git/git/blob/142430338477d9d1bb25be66267225fb58498d92/Documentation/RelNotes/1.7.10.txt#L128

hmleal · 2022-11-22T09:27:00Z

There's anything missing before merging this PR? This PR is going to speed up things for all users, it would be good have it merged

…n 'x'`

AndreasHassing · 2023-03-10T22:05:47Z

There's anything missing before merging this PR? This PR is going to speed up things for all users, it would be good have it merged

@hmleal From my side; just need tests to pass 😊. They pass on Windows but MacOS and Ubuntu are not behaving the same way.
Please hold while I go buy a Mac Mini 😉 /s, I'll see if this is a POSIX thing and attempt to repro in a tiny Azure Ubuntu VM 😄.

Edit: It's definitely something to do with POSIX vs Windows:

Linux	Windows

On Windows, git branch --no-color --list "*" returns all branches. On Linux, it returns nothing.

AndreasHassing · 2023-03-10T23:26:43Z

@dahlbyk & @rkeithhill: this is green now 😊. If you have a minute at some point, a review and potentially merge would be appreciated.

Thank you for your good work on this project!

AndreasHassing · 2024-10-03T06:40:28Z

@dahlbyk do you have a couple of minutes to take another peek at this? 🙂

This was referenced Dec 10, 2021

Add the Remove-PoshGitFromProfile function #877

Merged

Add a GitHub workflow #878

Merged

dahlbyk reviewed Mar 27, 2022

View reviewed changes

src/GitTabExpansion.ps1 Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

AndreasHassing force-pushed the improve-branch-autocompletion-time branch from c52bdcc to 42aa80d Compare April 4, 2022 12:55

AndreasHassing added 3 commits March 10, 2023 21:13

Merge branch 'dahlbyk:master' into improve-branch-autocompletion-time

df4de73

Tests: -contains 'x' | Should -Be $true => `| Should [-Not] -Contai…

3d3a0f3

…n 'x'`

Fix gitBranches returning symbolic refarrow+branch

1204fc1

AndreasHassing added 2 commits March 11, 2023 00:20

Should -Contain => Should -Be $true

8c6723c

Fix POSIX issue with git --list "*"

95e9f77

AndreasHassing requested a review from dahlbyk March 10, 2023 23:28

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Use `--list` for `branch` and `tag` tab expansion #864

Use `--list` for `branch` and `tag` tab expansion #864

AndreasHassing commented Jul 6, 2021 •

edited

Loading

AndreasHassing commented Jul 7, 2021 •

edited

Loading

dahlbyk commented Jul 7, 2021

dscho commented Dec 10, 2021

AndreasHassing commented Mar 17, 2022

dahlbyk commented Mar 27, 2022

AndreasHassing commented Mar 27, 2022

dahlbyk commented Mar 27, 2022

AndreasHassing commented Mar 27, 2022

dahlbyk left a comment

rkeithhill commented Mar 27, 2022

hmleal commented Nov 22, 2022

AndreasHassing commented Mar 10, 2023 •

edited

Loading

AndreasHassing commented Mar 10, 2023 •

edited

Loading

AndreasHassing commented Oct 3, 2024

Use --list for branch and tag tab expansion #864

Are you sure you want to change the base?

Use --list for branch and tag tab expansion #864

Conversation

AndreasHassing commented Jul 6, 2021 • edited Loading

AndreasHassing commented Jul 7, 2021 • edited Loading

dahlbyk commented Jul 7, 2021

dscho commented Dec 10, 2021

AndreasHassing commented Mar 17, 2022

dahlbyk commented Mar 27, 2022

AndreasHassing commented Mar 27, 2022

dahlbyk commented Mar 27, 2022

AndreasHassing commented Mar 27, 2022

dahlbyk left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

rkeithhill commented Mar 27, 2022

hmleal commented Nov 22, 2022

AndreasHassing commented Mar 10, 2023 • edited Loading

AndreasHassing commented Mar 10, 2023 • edited Loading

AndreasHassing commented Oct 3, 2024

Use `--list` for `branch` and `tag` tab expansion #864

Use `--list` for `branch` and `tag` tab expansion #864

AndreasHassing commented Jul 6, 2021 •

edited

Loading

AndreasHassing commented Jul 7, 2021 •

edited

Loading

AndreasHassing commented Mar 10, 2023 •

edited

Loading

AndreasHassing commented Mar 10, 2023 •

edited

Loading